Lean and Six Sigma are two methodologies that can and are frequently employed together.
Lean focuses on the breadth of a process, aiming to improve end-to-end ‘flow’ and reduce waste within a process. Six Sigma focuses on achieving an in-depth understanding of parts of a process in order to reduce variance and defects.
- Both concepts have exactly the same objective: continuous business process improvement.
- Both follow a structured approach to identify the root causes of a business problem and find the optimal solution to avoid recurrence of the problem.
- Six Sigma improves the capability of steps that do add value whereas Lean focuses on eliminating waste.
- Six Sigma is a data driven methodology, whereas Lean relies more on value stream maps and subsequent analysis.
What are Lean and Six Sigma and what are the key differences between them?
Lean
|
Six Sigma
|
Speed and efficiency by identifying value add and eliminating waste
|
Reducing variation, improving quality and stability by using a structured DMAIC approach
|
Realise more with less and at low costs
-
In a Lean process there is no ‘waste’ in terms of what is not valuable to the customer.
-
Activities are error proof, and defects are prevented. Workspace lay-out is optimal and easy to understand, everything is on-hand and easy to find.
|
Realise lower variation in a process/product quality
-
Six Sigma is a highly disciplined, quantitative, data-driven, fact based methodology focused on developing and delivering near-perfect products and services.
-
Six Sigma is a statistical measure of how far a given process deviates from perfection.
|
Voice of the customer
-
Business processes are viewed ‘end to end’ from the customers’ perspective – focus on what adds value to the customer.
-
Any activity in the workflow that adds time, effort or cost but does not create value to the customer is considered as necessary non value add and/or non-value add. These are considered two types of waste.
|
Voice of the customer
-
Similar to Lean, Six Sigma places the customer at the centre of process improvement to ensure customer’s needs are satisfied.
-
With the voice of the customer as a starting point Six Sigma focuses first on reducing process variance and then on improving the process capability.
|
Improve the whole system
-
Lean focuses on the end to end process and does not typically seek to improve the activities that create existing value for the customer.
-
Instead Lean seeks to identify and reduce waste to its lowest level by eliminating non value added activities (NVA) and minimising necessary non value added activities (NNVA).
|
Various diagnostic techniques
-
Six Sigma projects focus on improving the root-causes of the problem, instead of improving the symptoms.
-
Diagnostic techniques: Run and Control charts, ‘As-is’ process map, Critical to Quality Tree, Pareto Chart, Flowcharts, Histogram, Cause-and-Effect Diagram, Hypothesis Testing etc.
|